An Analysis And Comparison Of The Socialist And Zionist Ideological Calamities.

[By Jorge Besada. On X: @hayekian, hayekian@gmail.com]

Introduction.

European Imperialism, Nazism, and Socialism, should be seen, not as the result of simplistic malice or stupidity, but as flawed ideologies that understandably made sense to many intellectuals and well-intentioned people. As 1974 Nobel Laureate in Economics F.A. Hayek writes:

"It is necessary to realize that the sources of many of the most harmful agents in this world are often not evil men but high-minded idealists, and that in particular the foundations of totalitarian barbarism have been laid by honourable and well-meaning scholars who never recognized the offspring they produced." (Hayek, “Law, Legislation and Liberty, Volume 1: Rules and Order”, p. 70)

Hayek again:

”Most people are still unwilling to face the most alarming lesson of modern history: that the greatest crimes of our time have been committed by governments that had the enthusiastic support of millions of people who were guided by moral impulses. It is simply not true that Hitler or Mussolini, Lenin or Stalin, appealed only to the worst instincts of their people: they also appealed to some of the feelings which also dominate contemporary democracies.” (Hayek, “Law Legislation and Liberty. Volume 2: The Mirage of Social Justice”, p.134)

Just like Socialism was a flawed ideology that led to tyrannical-chaotic states like the Soviet Union and Maoist China, so is Zionism and resulting Israeli state. Zionism is similar to the ideologies above, yet far deadlier, because unlike their flaws, which have been relatively simple and already overcome, Zionism’s flaws are far more complex, thus fooling many of our brightest minds and still increasing their calamitous effects. To properly understand this we begin by briefly summarizing the recent emergence-evolution of the modern global free market capitalist order, followed by the rise of Socialist mythology and resulting Soviet Union which will provide an example of how intelligent people fool themselves into tyranny, and then we show how the same applies to Zionism and resulting Israeli state.

The Emergence of Capitalism and Socialist Mythology.

Until the late 1700s most people lived in small and nearly self-sufficient farming towns. As technology improved (printing press, engines-factories), the rate at which mankind could transform raw materials into wealth was rapidly increasing in cities. A growing class of businessmen-entrepreneurs-capitalists and their ‘private sector’ companies were constantly innovating, and due to people's ‘freedom to trade’ their ‘private property’ only for things they deemed superior, entrepreneurs also had to copy the innovations of competitors, inadvertently creating and spreading superior information-technology and subsequent socioeconomic order. Competition between increasingly wealthy-productive factories-businesses-entrepreneurs motivated them to pay increasing amounts of wealth relative to what workers earned in farms causing people to move to cities, quickly leading to massively complex metropolises-supercomputers and accelerating living standards.

Morals are information which also emerges and spreads via economic competition to considerable degrees. It is hard-working, courteous people-workers, that treat others-customers-coworkers with mutual respect in a manner that maximizes cooperation-production-profitability regardless of age-sex-religion-race, who thanks to competition, motivate everyone else to be likewise. As Hayek writes:

"Competition is, after all, always a process in which a small number makes it necessary for larger numbers to do what they do not like, be it to work harder, to change habits, or to devote a degree of attention, continuous application, or regularity to their work which without competition would not be needed." (Hayek, “Law Legislation and Liberty. Volume 3: The Political Order of a Free People, p. 77)

By the late 1800s most large cities in the world, from NYC to Shanghai, were increasingly being organized by private businessmen and citizens who wore some kind of business suit, priding themselves in hard work, honesty, self-reliance, toleration, and the wealth and prosperity they brought.

Now, very important! Were the above changes leading to the emergence of modern capitalism the result of the plans or design of some great intellectuals-leaders? No. Just like language is a complex and vital communication-coordination system that is, in the words of Adam Ferguson: “indeed the result of human action, but not the execution of any human design”, so are the socioeconomic institutions associated with Capitalism like private property, money, economic competition (summarized above), as Carl Menger writes: “the unintended product of historical development…the unintended result of individual human efforts (pursuing individual interests) without a common will directed toward their establishment.” Just like through a non-designed evolutionary process cells created the respiratory-digestive-nervous-etc. “systems” that coordinate multicellular life, so has man created the mechanisms (private property, money, finance-banking) that coordinate, what Menger and Herbert Spencer so cleverly called, ‘The Social Organism’.

Thus we can see how ‘private property’ and its emerging freedom and ‘competition of ideas’, as opposed to leading to chaos, is what 1) enables and motivates the discovery and spread of superior information and subsequent social order, 2) civilizes us, 3) protects us from being coerced into doing something we don’t want and thus allows us to live our lives as we wish, 4) and is vital for discovering the truth. Freedom is the ultimate algorithm!

Since these changes were “unintended”, their benefits were not widely understood which led to the rapid spread of a new erroneous ideology-mythology, Socialism. Misguided ideologues and resentful masses, fooled by the rapidly growing complexity of the socioeconomic order, increasingly thought that entrepreneurs and their companies were “exploiting” workers, leading to “unfair” differences in wealth, and that abolishing them or having them managed by a coercive-competition-immune-monopolistic bureaucracy of “experts” and “great leaders”, in other words, the state-government or the ‘public sector’, would be a better way of managing the socioeconomic order. An echo-chamber of intellectuals showing various levels of ignorance-incompetence-negligence would describe these increasingly popular fallacies-myths in a manner that was bound to go viral and that is what sort of happened with Karl Marx and his bite-sized “Communist Manifesto” where he famously writes: “the theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property.”

The Rise and Fall of the Soviet Union.

Lenin’s Bolshevik revolution in 1917 led to the attempted implementation of a Socialist state, the Soviet Union(1922). The Soviets’ expert-led “central plans” could not work if people were free not to fund or go along with them, so everyone had to be coerced via a massive police state that would both, criminalize dissent, and propagandize its myths-ideology making them much harder to change.

Without privately owned and thus competing companies, you’d now have a single coercive-competition-immune-monopolistic bureaucracy of “experts” with no incentives or pressure to innovate or copy existing innovations since there are no judicious customers to persuade-satisfy by learning from and working as hard as competitors. Without corporate profit-loss calculation, which ordered the actions of people-workers-companies in the private sector in a manner where more wealth was produced (sales revenue) than consumed (costs), thus ensuring profitability-growth, the future Socialist-Soviet-Maoist bureaucracies-orders would consume more than produce leading to eventual famines and chaos. The Soviets-Socialists did achieve some technological progress because they would copy the improvements companies in the free-competitive non-Socialist countries were creating.

Kulaks, farmers who employed and thus profited from laborers, would be seen as greedy-immoral “exploiters” to be killed with impunity. Lenin orders:

“Hang (I mean hang publicly, so that people see it) at least 100 kulaks, rich bastards, and known blood-suckers…Publish their names…Seize all their grain.” (“The Black Book of Communism”, p. 72)

Socialist movements inadvertently had massive Jewish overrepresentation. There is Jewish leading Socialist ideologue Karl Marx. Lenin’s sidekick and founder of the Red Army, Leon Trotsky (born Lev Davidovich Bronstein), was offered by Lenin to be the first leader of what would become the Soviet Union, but Trotsky turned down the idea and told Lenin: ‘You know very well that a Jew can’t be Premier in Russia’. Jewish Author Yuri Slezkine writes in his excellent book ‘The Jewish Century’: "At the First All-Russian Congress of Soviets in June 1917, at least 31 percent of Bolshevik delegates(and 37 percent of Unified Social Democrats) were Jews.” Furthermore, 5 of the 12 Bolshevik Central Committee Members at the October 10, 1917 meeting which voted to launch an armed insurrection were ethnic Jews. Jews, at least in Lenin’s Russia, were on average better educated, thus inadvertently rising to the top of the tyrannical ideology-bureaucracy which required the better-educated to coerce the rest. Lenin mentions how: “Jewish intelligentsia members in the Russian cities was of great importance to the revolution…It was only thanks to this pool of a rational and literate labor force that we succeeded in taking over the state apparatus.” The atheism and Darwinism associated with Socialism had an extra appeal for Jews since they’d now gain equality and freedom from religion-influenced restrictions. This not only further contributed to their over-representation in the horrible movement, but also in the tyrannical Soviet secret police tasked with eliminating the “irrational” religious Christians-Muslims-Jews who got in the way of Socialist ideology-morality. Slezkine again:

“In 1923, at the time of the creation of the OGPU(the Cheka's successor), Jews made up 15.5 percent of all "leading" officials and 50 percent of the top brass (4 out of 8 members of the Collegium's Secretariat).“Socially alien” Jews were well represented among Cheka-OGPU prisoners, too, but Leonard Schapiro is probably justified in generalizing (especially about the territory of the former Pale) that “anyone who had the misfortune to fall into the hands of the Cheka stood a very good chance of finding himself confronted with and possibly shot by a Jewish investigator.”” (Slezkine, “The Jewish Century”)

In just 13 years, from 1927-1940, the Soviet secret police, with a significant over-representation of ethic Jews, destroyed 29,084 Christian Orthodox Churches leaving less than 500, while killing an estimated 80,000-100,000 priests. Unlike Jews in the rest of the Western World who had gained equality under the law many decades earlier (US and France in 1791, Ottoman Empire(1856), United Kingdom (1858), Austro-Hungarian Empire (1867), German Empire(1871)), the existing Russian bureaucracy still had many dehumanizing restrictions on Jews understandably leading many to have an additional fervor for revenge and further fool themselves with Socialist myths.

The above factors erroneously made it seem to naïve thinkers like Hitler, and sadly many to this day, that “The Jews” purposely conspired Socialism for nefarious purposes including destroying Christianity-Islam-Religion, instead of the truth, that complex historical-cultural-environmental factors, NOT malicious conspiracy, led to ethnic Jews being over-represented in a disastrous ideology.

Religious people understandably saw the Socialists who were persecuting them, not as economically-ideologically misguided, but as being “evil”, “Satanic”, etc., which the atheist-Darwinian Socialists found absurd. This made it even easier for Socialists to ridicule and persecute with immense negligence and cruelty the religious people who were preventing the great progress ‘Scientific Socialism’ would allegedly bring.

Emerging Marxist morality (adhere to expert plans) and existing religious morality (God-given rights-freedoms, 10 commandments, etc.) clashed, overlooking the root economic errors-fallacies-ideas fueling the chaos. Mises elaborates in one of my favorite and vital sections of his treatise Human Action aptly called ‘The Fight Against Error’:

"The problems involved are purely intellectual and must be dealt with as such[via reason, logic, education]. It is disastrous to shift them to the moral sphere and to dispose of supporters of opposite ideologies by calling them villains… The rigid dogmatism peculiar to religious groups and to Marxism results only in irreconcilable conflict. It condemns beforehand all dissenters as evildoers, it calls into question their good faith, it asks them to surrender unconditionally. No social cooperation is possible where such an attitude prevails. No better is the propensity, very popular nowadays, to brand supporters of other ideologies as lunatics."

Thus per Mises, people are neither malicious or “evil”, nor stupid or crazy, for the most part they just fall for economically flawed ideologies.

The same polarizations and chaos would emerge as Jews and people making anti-Jewish fallacies (Hitler-Nazis), as well as Zionists and anti-Zionists, vilified each other overlooking the complex history and errors from which the misunderstandings and hatreds arose. Per Mises, it is vitally important that we focus on the ideas-fallacies:

"It is ideas that group men into fighting factions, that press the weapons into their hands, and that determine against whom and for whom the weapons shall be used. It is they alone, and not arms, that, in the last analysis, turn the scales." (Mises, “Liberalism”, p. 51)

And that we likewise look at history trying to understand how people fooled themselves into disastrous ideologies instead of just making “condemnations”:

“Neither as judges allotting praise and blame nor as avengers seeking out the guilty should we face the past. We seek truth, not guilt; we want to know how things came about to understand them, not to issue condemnations.” (Mises, “Nation, State and Economy”, p. 27)

“History should teach us to recognize causes and to understand driving forces; and when we understand everything, we will forgive everything.” (Mises, “Nation, State and Economy”, p. 28)

The Socialists-Soviets, by granting equal rights to women, being the first to put a man in space (Yuri Gagarin), having the most chess champions, and other cosmetic achievements, kept fooling themselves into thinking they were the vanguard of civilization while in reality their ideology-Socialism was by far the most uncivilized-tyrannical-disastrous.

It is important to see Socialism for what it is-was, a disastrous emerging-evolving ideology-myth-software-identity and NOT some simplistic malicious-immoral conspiracy. The great comedian-critic George Carlin astutely mentioned: “You don’t need a formal conspiracy when interests converge.” Ideologies cause people to have shared interests-incentives-fears-concerns-views which causes them to think and act alike giving the impression that they are in a ‘formal conspiracy’ when in reality no such thing has likely occurred. And even when ‘formal conspiracies’ do occur, we must focus on the complex emergence-evolution of the “ideas that group men”.

Eventually, significantly thanks to Carl Menger and his intellectual descendants known as ‘The Austrian School of Economics’, like Ludwig von Mises and F.A. Hayek who explained all the fallacies, and after enough failures and suffering, enough minds were changed and the Soviets got their “reformers”. 1976 Nobel Laureate in Economics Milton Friedman mentions how: “There is…no person who had more of an influence on the intellectuals behind the iron curtain than Friedrich Hayek.” Gorbachev mentions: “[Communism] in principle, as a system, as a philosophy, as a model of organizing society, of reforming society, has to be rejected.” The Zionists currently find themselves in a similarly disastrous situation.

The Emergence of Zionism and its polarizing effects.

Given the understandable intellectual ignorance-backwardness of the past, throughout history Jews have been erroneously blamed for many things like The Black Plague. Inadvertent Jewish overrepresentation in both, Atheistic-Socialist movements, as well as banking-finance-Capitalism, also brought Jews scorn from people who disliked or misunderstood both Socialism and Capitalism. Theodor Herzl, the founder of political Zionism, over 20 years before the Jewish-overrepresented Bolsheviks-Socialists gained power, brilliantly summarized the situation when he writes in his seminal book ‘The Jewish State’(1896),:

"We are what the Ghetto made us. We have attained pre-eminence in finance, because mediaeval conditions drove us to it. The same process is now being repeated. We are again being forced into finance, now it is the stock exchange, by being kept out of other branches of economic activity. Being on the stock exchange, we are consequently exposed afresh to contempt. At the same time we continue to produce an abundance of mediocre intellects who find no outlet, and this endangers our social position as much as does our increasing wealth. Educated Jews without means are now rapidly becoming Socialists. Hence we are certain to suffer very severely in the struggle between classes, because we stand in the most exposed position in the camps of both Socialists and capitalists." (Herzl, ‘The Jewish State’(1896))

Herzl is astutely referring to mediaeval Christendom’s and the Islamic world’s restrictions on moneylending for Christians and Muslims which unintendedly made Jews the prominent financiers-bankers. Historian Paul Johnson writes:

“The Jews reacted by engaging in the one business where Christian laws actually discriminated in their favour, and so became identified with the hated trade of moneylending. Rabbi Joseph Colon, who knew both France and Italy in the second half of the fifteenth century, wrote that the Jews of both countries hardly engaged in any other profession”

Moneylending-finance-banking and the phenomenon of interest rates greatly help society in two ways. One, they allow entrepreneurs to have access to greater quantities of wealth needed to carry out big projects (skyscrapers, factories, etc.) And two, they motivate people whose inferior potential business ideas DO NOT have a return on investment greater than prevailing interest rates to save, and thus accumulate and place the wealth they would have otherwise consumed under the control of borrowers-entrepreneurs whose ideas DO have a return on investment greater than prevailing interest rates as they make a profit large enough to pay back the loans with interest. This process inadvertently, NOT as the result of our “reason”, but as Carl Menger would write “as unintended results of historical development” gives a massive computational boost to society as wealth is accumulated and subsequently used to reorder society by the minds that have the best ideas-information. The interest rate is like a barometer that inadvertently helps a mind-CPU decide whether it should do the saving or borrowing. See my article ‘Interest Rates, Computational Boosts, and the Austrian Theory of the Business Cycle’).

This inadvertently gave Jews immense influence by placing them at the heart of the growing global capitalist order and other beneficial financial innovations like stock markets which gave the erroneous impression to naive economically ignorant thinkers that this was not only detrimental, but some reasoned plot or conspiracy, or per Hitler, tied to Jewish “characteristics”. Hitler’s fallacies could be seen in a 1922 speech where he mentioned:

“thus bit by bit the Stock Exchange came to control the whole national economy. The directors of these institutions were, and are without exception, Jews. I say ‘without exception,’ for the few non-Jews who had a share in them are in the last resort nothing but screens, shop-window Christians, whom one needs in order, for the sake of the masses, to keep up the appearance that these institutions were after all founded as a natural outcome of the needs and the economic life of all peoples alike, and were not, as was the fact, institutions which correspond only with the essential characteristics of the Jewish people and are the outcome of those characteristics.”

Furthermore, a more secular-Darwinian-evolutionary outlook, less tied to culturally evolved religious morals, unintendedly caused Jews to be relative leaders in pornography, LGBT stuff which helps explain why Tel Aviv today may be the gay capital of the world, Hollywood (Marlon Brando: “Hollywood is run by Jews. It’s owned by Jews.”), scientific research, and ideological movements whose views deviated from established religious traditions, further causing misguided thinkers, especially religious ones, to “blame” “the Jews” for alleged “immorality”, “debauchery”, etc.

Jewish involvement and influence in such movements-industries is not the result of malicious conspiracy by allegedly all-powerful Jews, it is the result of complex evolved cultural factors and thus: “indeed the result of human action, but not the execution of any human design.”

Unfortunately, instead of overcoming anti-Jewish fallacies via reason, logic, and education, which are the only ways to overcome fallacies, Jews and rightly sympathetic supporters, as well as people wanting to get rid of Jews, fooled themselves into attempting to overcome Jew-Gentile misunderstandings-frictions by encouraging Jews to leave the humble Synagogues and towns-cities, where they were really from and had lived for centuries, to create a “Jewish State” in the holiest of locations in the Western World and overwhelmingly populated by Muslims, Christians, and fellow Jews who for understandable reasons were adamantly opposed to living in a “Jewish State”, with a coerced Jewish flag, anthem, and overall “identity”. A state that would be concocted by misguided European ideologues who inherited some of the imperialist-racist and Socialist fallacies of their times. David ben Gurion, Israel’s first Prime Minister, eagerly attended Moscow in 1923 to celebrate the 7th anniversary of the Bolsheviks’ October Revolution. Benzion Netanyahu (Bibi’s dad) wrote-believed absurdities like: “If a nation says out of conviction, I am strong and forceful, then it becomes strong and forceful. This is the law of greatness.” Impressive if written in cursive by a four-year-old, but an absurd basis for creating a country in the holiest of locations.

For Zionist ideologues, overcoming anti-Jewish fallacies was never a priority. Antisemitism was actually needed and welcomed “to spur on the movement”. Herzl writes:

“The anti-semites will be our most steadfast friends.” “The anti-Semitic countries will be our allies.” “Great exertions will hardly be necessary to spur on the movement. Anti-Semites provide the requisite impetus. They need only do what they did before, and then they will create a desire to emigrate where it did not previously exist, and strengthen it where it existed before.”

Zionist ideologues, being equally human, were just as misguided-ignorant-negligent, and sometimes dangerously fanatical, as Lenin and his Bolsheviks. In 1920, Chaim Weizmann, the leading Zionist figure after Herzl’s death in 1904 wrote:

“We will establish ourselves in Palestine whether you like it or not...You can hasten our arrival or you can equally retard it. It is however better for you to help us so as to avoid our constructive powers being turned into a destructive power which will overthrow the world.”

Instead of having an ideology-identity-culture-software that could spread the TRUTH, that freedom and individual rights were increasing and anti-Jewish restrictions (along with slavery, unequal treatment of women, etc.) were decreasing, we now had the evolution of a Zionist identity-ideology that would grow by doing the opposite, by bringing attention to, amplifying, and attempting to eradicate anti-Jewish fallacies with increased vilification, separation and violence. A process that could only increase anti-Jewish fallacies, polarizations and wars.

In his MUST-BE-READ classic essay 'The Iron Wall' (1923), long before the rise of Nazi Germany, Vladimir Jabotinsky, one of the most important Zionist ideologues wrote:

"There can be no voluntary agreement between ourselves and the Palestine Arabs. Not now, nor in the prospective future…. it is utterly impossible to obtain the voluntary consent of the Palestine Arabs for converting "Palestine" from an Arab country into a country with a Jewish majority…Culturally they [Arabs] are five hundred years behind us, they have neither our endurance nor our determination…We hold that Zionism is moral and just. And since it is moral and just, justice must be done, no matter whether Joseph or Simon or Ivan or Achmet agree with it or not. There is no other morality."

Just like Socialist identity-morality replaced the previous identity-morality of many Russians and Chinese as it attempted to create the “Socialist man” who “was to be selfless, learned, healthy, muscular, and enthusiastic in spreading the communist Revolution”, so would Zionism drive extinct the organically grown Judaism which was overwhelmingly opposed to Zionism. The rabbinical establishment, reflecting views shared by most Jews in Munich, Germany, where Herzl wanted to hold the First Zionist Congress (1897), strongly rejected the idea so the meeting was moved to Basel, Switzerland. They mentioned:

“…we comprise a separate community solely with respect to religion. Regarding nationality, we feel totally at one with our fellow Germans and therefore strive towards the realization of the spiritual and moral goals of our dear fatherland with an enthusiasm equaling theirs.” (Protestrabbiner, "Protest against Zionism," trans. M. Gelber, in The Jewish Chronicle, July 9, 1897, p. 9.)

Chaim Weizmann lamented how:

“For assimilated Jews…They looked upon it…as a primitive tribalism. They felt themselves…called upon to “rescue” Judaism from Zionism…these people are dead against Zionism” (Weizmann, “Trial And Error”, p. 227)

Of course! That rapidly increasing number of very well educated cosmopolitan “assimilated Jews” spread all over Europe-USA just wanted to be fellow human beings or equal world citizens free of ancient tribalisms-mysticisms-identities. Similarly, living in some secular state concocted by an atheist like Herzl, who arrogantly wanted to overcome antisemitism by having the Pope convert Jews to Christianity, was abhorrent-blasphemous to religious Jews. Unfortunately, for very understandable reasons-factors for which nobody is to blame and are ultimately rooted in economic ignorance, like a rocket that is just about to reach orbit but runs out of fuel and comes crashing down to earth, Zionism would inadvertently pull ‘Jewish Identity’ and all of Western Civilization back to an increasingly ethnocentric identity-vs.-identity-worldview with disastrous consequences. The “Zionification” of Judaism, led by a bunch of Atheists (Herzl, ben Gurion, etc.), replaced “identities”-cultures which shared a common language and strived “towards the realization of the spiritual and moral goals of” the towns, cities, countries they were a part of and shared with non-Jews, for a separatist-exclusive Zionist identity that was ultimately tied to the fallacies of coercing millions into living under a ‘Jewish State’ and overcoming anti-Jewish errors via force and vilification. Unfortunately and in many ways predictably, Zionist fallacies-ideology and Hitler’s anti-Jewish fallacies kept fermenting each other leading to WWII and the further “Zionification” of Jews and the West.

Hitler of course held anti-Jewish fallacies already discussed, however, vilifying and attempting to destroy people making errors, instead of overcoming them via reason and education, is also a mistake just as responsible for all the polarizations and chaos.

To what degree can one deem people criminals when their harms are the result of the emergence of a complex and ultimately flawed ideology? The legal concept of ‘mens rea’ (guilty mind) is something we must keep in mind when dealing with millions who fool themselves into flawed ideologies-moralities like Socialism, Nazism, European Imperialism, etc., and Zionism.

Hitler became Chancellor on January 30, 1933. On March 27, 1933 The American Jewish Congress, led by Zionist Rabbi Stephen S. Wise, organized a major protest rally against Hitler at Madison Square Garden in New York City which was attended by over 55,000 people and called for a boycott of German goods. Cyrus Adler, president of the American Jewish Committee was one of the many voices against such a direct escalation with the German government. His committee’s Jewish contacts in Germany were strongly opposed to such rallies and polarizing vilifications. New York Supreme Court Justice Joseph M. Proskauer wisely expressed his concerns against “causing more trouble for the Jews in Germany by unintelligent action.” Unfortunately, the “Zionized” mindset and its simplistic us vs. them, good vs. evil mindset which easily appeals to our tribal and mob instincts overtook the more cautious thinkers trying to understand and overcome the fallacies. 5 days after on April 1st, Germany’s Minister of Propaganda, Joseph Goebbels, organized a one-day boycott of Jewish businesses which would be lifted if anti-Nazi protests were suspended which obviously did not happen since in simplistic-tribalistic thinking the good homo sapiens obviously must never give into the evil homo sapiens. On April 7th. Hitler’s government passes the ‘Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service’ which begins legal restrictions on Jews by preventing them from having various government jobs. The polarizations, especially by the “Zionized” Jews, understandably increased. On January, 1934 over 5 years before start of WWII Jabotinsky wrote:

"For months now the struggle against Germany is waged by each Jewish community, at each conference, in all our syndicates, and by each Jew all over the world…We will trigger a spiritual and material war of all the world against Germany's ambitions to become once again a great nation, to recover lost territories and colonies. But our Jewish interests demand the complete destruction of Germany. Collectively and individually, the German nation is a threat to us Jews."

The increasingly “Zionized” Jews and their supporters did nothing to understand-overcome anti-Jewish fallacies, misrepresented Hitler as some non-homo sapiens maniacal conqueror instead of the average European bureaucrat with popular anti-Jewish fallacies that he was, prevented him from rightly overturning the wrongs of the ‘Treaty of Versailles’, like reuniting the Danzig Germans, thus forcing Hitler to do it by force. And then fooled themselves and the world into an unnecessary massive world war that led to over 80 million deaths and further disastrous expansion of Communism. Only “Zionized” minds could see Hitler and the courteous, pious, civilized Germans, as a greater menace than Stalin. As awful and uncivilized as Hitler’s racist-antisemitic Nuremberg Race Laws were, which prevented Jews from marrying non-Jews, according to Grok-AI, 1,500 to 2,500 Jews died in Germany in the 6.5 year span since Hitler rose to power (1933) till WWII began (1939). With many of these deaths coming during the Kristallnacht riots (9-10 of Nov. 1938) which had been sparked when a Jew assassinated a German diplomat. As awful and uncivilized as this was, it was an insignificant number compared to the estimated 5,400 to 15,400 PER WEEK Stalin killed just during his ‘Great Purge’(1936-8). This “Zionification” also erroneously portrayed the Japanese, due to their alliance with Hitler, as some uncivilized conquerors, and again, worse than Stalin. The truth is, that even with Hitler’s naive government-sanctioned discrimination against Jews, the average Jew was better off in Hitler’s pre-war Germany than an average Russian in Stalin’s Soviet Union. And the Japanese, significantly due to their admiration of freemarketeer Herbert Spencer who was the most widely read Western intellectual and even in close correspondence with Japanese leaders as they crafted their laws-reforms, were a rapidly progressing and civilizing force in Asia, especially compared to the Maoist Communist calamity that replaced them.

Sadly the simplistic-tribalistic ‘good vs. evil’ mindset that the Jews were understandably creating in the USA as an understandable reaction to Nazi antisemitism was no match for the reason of more nuanced thinkers like the great American hero, and first man to fly non-stop across the Atlantic Ocean, Charles Lindbergh who mentioned in a famous speech at Des Moines on September 11, 1941:

“It is not difficult to understand why Jewish people desire the overthrow of Nazi Germany. The persecution they suffered in Germany would be sufficient to make bitter enemies of any race. No person with a sense of the dignity of mankind can condone the persecution of the Jewish race in Germany. But no person of honesty and vision can look on their pro-war policy here today without seeing the dangers involved in such a policy both for us and for them. Instead of agitating for war, the Jewish groups in this country should be opposing it in every possible way for they will be among the first to feel its consequences. Tolerance is a virtue that depends upon peace and strength. History shows that it cannot survive war and devastations. A few far-sighted Jewish people realize this and stand opposed to intervention. But the majority still do not.”

Such reasonable and unfortunately prophetic statements led to accusations that Lindbergh was an anti-Semite even though, as his wife would tell a journalist in 1980, “in the 45 years I lived with him I never heard him make a remark against Jews, not a crack or a joke, neither did any of my children.”

On February 9th 1938, almost 7 months before the outbreak of WWII, the Polish Ambassador in Washington, Count Jerzy Potocki, reported back home to the Foreign Minister in Warsaw on the Jewish role “in creating a war psychosis which would plunge the entire world into war”:

“The Jews are right now the leaders in creating a war psychosis which would plunge the entire world into war and bring about general catastrophe. This mood is becoming more and more apparent.…This hatred has become a frenzy. It is propagated everywhere and by every means: in theaters, in the cinema, and in the press. The Germans are portrayed as a nation living under the arrogance of Hitler which wants to conquer the whole world and drown all of humanity in an ocean of blood. In conversations with Jewish press representatives I have repeatedly come up against the inexorable and convinced view that war is inevitable. This international Jewry exploits every means of propaganda to oppose any tendency towards any kind of consolidation and understanding between nations.” (Marc Webber, “President Roosevelt’s Campaign To Incite War in Europe: The Secret Polish Documents”)

On September 10th 1941, about 3 months before the US entered WWII (11/8/1941) Chaim Weizmann sends a letter to Churchill mentioning how Jews helped England defeat Germany in World War One by bringing the United States into the war and how they will help England do the same thing again:

“…Two years have passed since, on the outbreak of the war I offered to His Majesty’s government, on behalf of the Jewish people, the fullest active support of Jews in Palestine and throughout the world…I have spent months in America, traveling up and down the country, and clearly searching the American scene. Forces over there are finely balanced; the position is uncertain. There is only one big ethnic group which is willing to stand, to a man, for Great Britain, and a policy of “all-out-aid” for her: the five million American Jews. From Secretary Morgenthau, Governor Lehman, Justice Frankfurter, down to the simplest Jewish workman or trader, they are conscious of all that this struggle against Hitler implies. It has been repeatedly acknowledged by British Statesmen that it was the Jews who, in the last war, effectively helped to tip the scales in America in favour of Great Britain. They are keen to do it - and may do it - again .”

After the US entered the war, Chaim Weizmann, mentioned the obvious: "this war is our war". In a speech on December 3, 1942, in New York he mentioned:

"We are not denying and are not afraid to confess that this war is our war and that it is waged for the liberation of Jewry… Stronger than all fronts together is our front, that of Jewry. We are not only giving this war our financial support on which the entire war production is based, we are not only providing our full propaganda power which is the moral energy that keeps this war going.”

Again, for very understandable reasons, the increasingly “Zionized” Jews and their supporters did their utmost to destroy Hitler and they succeeded at the cost of WWII and all that emerged from it.

Mises’ pupil and fellow Jew, economist Murray Rothbard wisely and courageously summarizes the truth-reality:

“Germany and Hitler were not uniquely guilty of launching World War II (indeed they were scarcely guilty at all);…Hitler, in brief, (in foreign affairs) was not a uniquely evil monster or daimon, who would continue to gobble up countries diabolically until stopped by superior force…Hitler had no designs, no plans, not even vague intimations, to expand westward against Britain and France (let alone the United States). Hitler admired the British Empire and wished to collaborate with it. Not only did Hitler do this with insight, he did it with patience, as Taylor excellently shows…” (Rothbard, “Review of The Origins of the Second World War”)

The same ideological patterns keep repeating. “Zionized” Jews and their supporters understandably evolved an ideological and incentive structure which led to the vilification and destruction of Germany due to Hitler’s naive anti-Jewish fallacies. Then, by continuing to tie their sense of morality and very “identity” to Zionism, critics of Zionism became the next “irrational terrorists”, antisemites, and “Hitlers” leading to “Zionized” US presidents like George W. Bush who mentions “Either you’re with us, or you are with the terrorists.” “Either you’re with us, either you love freedom, and with nations which embrace freedom, or you’re with the enemy. There is no in between.”

Let’s fast-forward to the first Trump Presidency. Another simple-minded naive and extremely dangerous “Zionized” Evangelical Christian is Former US Secretary of State as well as Director of the CIA, Mike Pompeo, whose ideological “Zionification” of the United States’ CIA is especially dangerous, and akin to the transformation of Russia’s pre-Socialist Tsar’s secret police (the Okhrana) to the Socialism-enforcing Cheka-NKVD-OGPU-KGB. Pompeo writes regarding the deep connection he has with Mossad chief Yossi Cohen:

”Being men of deep faith also solidified our bonds. Yossi and his wife, Aya, are Orthodox Jews. As evangelical Christians, Susan and I understood that our tradition wasn’t just Christian - it was Judeo- Christian. Yossi and I each understood the importance of Israel within our respective faith traditions and why this remarkable land was worth fighting to preserve. Talking with Yossi helped me realize, contrary to the later baying of the media hounds, that being open about my faith life didn’t scuttle my efforts on behalf of America - it strengthened them. Our abiding respect for one another flowed directly from talking about our imperfect, lifelong journey to honor God. It made the late nights when Yossi and I shared good bourbon and cigars together even more special. During my time in the administration, there would be no more capable partner and, as it turns out, no better friend in the world than Yossi. While much of the work that Yossi and I did must remain secret, I can tell you that the model we developed has saved countless American and Israeli lives. We were able to build a scaffolding that let President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu work with our friends and partners in the region and take risks that, absent this clandestine work, they might not have been able to accept. It was a 180- degree pivot from what had preceded the Trump administration.” (Pompeo, “Never Give An Inch”)

Pompeo, being thoroughly “Zionized”, understandably sees the Iranian government as pure evil and anyone who sees things differently is engaging in ‘sheer madness’. He writes:

“The Iranian regime is a de facto terrorist group....the Obama administration’s overeducated liberals.... decided that they knew better and sought to cut a deal with Iran. They believed that they could transform due-hard Islamists into responsible partners in peace...It was sheer madness.”

Some of these ‘overeducated liberals’ are people who believe all homo sapiens can eventually overcome misunderstandings and have peace, but of course, this is ‘sheer madness’ to a “Zionized” mind. Pompeo understandably sees Putin, who treated former Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad and the Iranians as fellow homo sapiens instead of some ‘evildoers’, as “a very smart, bad guy....Putin and his ilk are constantly looking to weaken our defenses and split our alliances.”

To a naïve, “Zionized”, ‘good vs. evil’ thinker like Pompeo the immense complexities and history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict can be described as:

“This land, as an evangelical Christian, I am convinced from my reading of the Bible that 3,000 years onto now, in spite of the denial of so many, is the rightful homeland of the Jewish people,”

Pompeo understandably radiates the ‘good vs. evil’, with-us or against-us tribalistic mentality in all directions with his hatred of famed heroic journalists and whistleblowers Julian Assange (founder of wikileaks) and Edward Snowden whom he referred to as ‘simple hoodlums’ and writes:

”villains such as Assange...Edward Snowden, Chelsea Manning...They certainly aren’t journalists. If they are foreigners, they are enemies. If they are Americans, they are traitors.... These crooks claim to be honoring human rights and free expression. They are in fact serving the interests of the most evil and repressive regimes... These enemies and traitors must be punished... I pursued Assange’s extradition hard as CIA director and secretary of state.... I lobbied the Ecuadorians to kick Assange out of his pathetic accommodations inside their embassy, and they finally capitulated...I will be delighted the day he is thrown into an American federal penitentiary. Just one less useful idiot free for Russia to exploit-and a warning to all such scoundrels in the future.” (Pompeo, “Never Give An Inch”)

In the naïve battle of ‘good vs. evil’, your side of homo sapiens can never do any wrong. He writes:

“I was right in that waterboarding worked. And the CIA men and women who were tasked with collecting intelligence....operate with the highest respect for the law.”

The “Zionized” vilifications of Hitler and Putin are nearly identical. Putin’s rightly cordial and sympathetic treatment of anti-Zionists like the Palestinians and their allies like Bashar al-Assad and Iran, is likewise making him the next “irrational” non-homo sapiens maniacal Hitler who allegedly wants to conquer Europe. As with Hitler who had no desire to conquer Europe and understandably invaded Poland as a last resort to reunite the Danzig Germans, so did the very reasonable Putin invade Eastern Ukraine as a last resort to defend and bring autonomy to the overwhelmingly Russian population of Eastern Ukraine and prevent continued NATO military expansion. This does NOT mean that there is some nefarious conspiracy directing things from Jerusalem, again: “You don’t need a formal conspiracy when interests converge.” “Zionized” Jews like former United States Deputy Secretary of State Victoria Nuland, former Secretary of State Antony Blinken, “Zionized” Christian Evangelicals like Pompeo and countless other “Zionized” ideologues’ “interests converge” playing leading roles in sparking wars like the Russia-Ukraine war. Again, WITHOUT the need of some Jerusalem-coordinated “conspiracy”. On March 5th 2022, just 9 days after the outbreak of the Russia-Ukraine war, Israeli Prime Minister at the time, Naftali Bennett, flew to Russia and spent hours with Putin helping negotiate an early peace, which was then significantly derailed by UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson and other ideologues. If “The Zionists” were some malicious conspirators, the Naftali efforts would have never occurred.

This simplistic-tribalistic “good vs. evil” ideology continues to spread and now dominates the “Zionized” American and European politicians, with simpletons like Ukrainian leader Zelensky (Jewish-Zionist of course, what a coincidence) mentioning: “You can mediate between countries, but not between good and evil.” Re-read Potocki’s quote, and notice how “Zionized” Jews like Ben Shapiro and Mark Levin “are right now the leaders in creating a war psychosis which would plunge the entire world into war and bring about general catastrophe.”

The great Russian diplomat and Minister of Foreign Affairs, Sergey Lavrov, told journalist Pepe Escobar in June 2025 that “I don't understand why we cannot have an adult dialogue.” The answer is because the US government has been totally “Zionized” just like Jews-Israelis have. Former Texas Gov. and one of the leading Republican presidential hopefuls of 2012, Rick Perry stated that: “As a Christian I have a clear directive to support Israel, from my perspective it’s pretty easy both as an American and a Christian. I am going to stand with Israel.” This religious-based Zionism can be seen as 'Right-Wing' Zionism. The Zionism of the US Republican Party and the white American Christian masses who easily find unity with fellow white-European-American Ashkenazi Jews. But we also have Left-Wing Zionism, the Zionism of the Left, of the secular-Darwinian intellectuals. These are the very successful secular Jews like Zuckerberg, CEO of Oracle and one time richest man in the world as well as top donor to the Israel Defense Forces Larry Ellison, and their similarly-minded intellectuals who see the Muslim world as religious fanatics and fellow secular LGBT-rights-supporting and secular ‘followers of the science’ Jews-Israelis as the good and "civilized" people. As former speaker of the house Nancy Pelosi mentioned: “if the Capitol crumbles to the ground, the one thing that would remain is our commitment to Israel…that’s fundamental.” So just like both religious-Right and secular-Left Jews “Zionized” themselves, they “Zionized” the American and European Left and Right too.

Deadly winds, saboteurs, 40 beheaded babies and gas-chambers.

It would be a gigantic error to call meteorologists as a group-profession liars just because sporadically we can find footage of them exaggerating-faking much stronger winds in storms which they do for a mixture of sensationalism-ratings, and to scare the public into being more careful. Socialists-Soviets would exaggerate the alleged harms of capitalists-saboteurs-kulaks-counterrevolutionaries-etc. who sabotaged the great prosperity Socialism would otherwise bring. Similarly, both Jews and non-Jews have evolved a culture that sometimes exaggerates the alleged wickedness of each other. Obvious evidence of this evolved cultural trait can be seen in the 40-beheaded babies myths that quickly spread during the initial months of the Israeli-Hamas war based on the lies-exaggerations of one Israeli tasked with gathering dead bodies(See the excellent “Atrocity Inc” documentary). Just like Soviet bureaucrats would seldom admit failure, or having gone along with lies-exaggerations, neither would Netanyahu issue an apology for spreading such a horrible lie-myth. Even more significant, books like 'The First Holocaust: The Surprising Origin of the Six-Million Figure', document with easy-to-verify references how the killing-extermination-plight of 6 million Jews has appeared in newspapers since the year 1850 at least over 200 times before the alleged extermination via gas-chambers could have taken place and be widely known. Jews spreading this ‘misinformation’ is NOT the result of some sinister ‘formal conspiracy’. Again, as happened in the Soviet Union and with weathermen, and per Carlin, it is the understandable result of complex cultural-ideological factors, incentives, statistical probabilities, and NOT some grand sinister conspiracy.

Jews fooled themselves and those around them into believing that Hitler attempted to exterminate Jewry via gas-chambers. How could this have happened!? Was this the result of a massive lie by Zionists to gain support and silence critics? Of course not. What essentially happened was that during the post war Nuremberg Trials, the Soviets-Stalin’s legal team, led by Andrey Vyshinsky, who was the same prosecutor who oversaw the infamous Stalin “Show Trials”(1936-8), introduced obviously fabricated “evidence”, which can be easily verified in the official Trial documents and has been gathered by Carlos Porter in his book ‘Made In Russia: The Holocaust’, that the evil non-homo sapiens maniacal Nazis killed people via steam chambers, electrical chambers, atomic bomb-like device, a pedal-driven brain bashing machine, and a bone-grinding machine among other obviously fabricated methods. See the excellent documentary ‘The Holocaust: Proven at Nuremberg Reviewing the Evidence Presented at the International Military Tribunal’.

Here is a great example of Vyshinsky’s legal oratory during the ‘Show Trials’:

“Shoot these rabid dogs! Death to this gang who hide their ferocious teeth, their eagle claws, from the people! Down with that vulture Trotsky, from whose mouth a bloody venom drips, putrefying the great ideals of Marxism!” (“The Black Book of Communism”, p. 750)

Secular Jewish-born researcher Ron Unz who has degrees in Physics and Ancient history from Harvard, brilliantly summarized the emergence of Holocaust myths-exaggerations in a presentation where he mentions:

“Take for example…the whole issue of the Nuremberg trials and…these horrible atrocities the Nazis supposedly committed…Many of the issues raised at the Nuremberg trials are obviously false…There had been all these accusations of human skin lampshades, shrunken heads, I mean all of it was totally nonsense nobody believes in these days… One of the things the Nazis were accused of at the Nuremberg trials, by the Soviet prosecutor[Andrey Vyshinsky], was that they massacred the Polish officer corps at the Katyn Forest, and everybody knew at the time it was…Stalin. It was the Soviets who'd done it… And the Soviet prosecutor at the Nuremberg trials[Vyshinsky] was the same man who'd been the chief Soviet prosecutor at the Stalin purge trials a few years earlier…when all these old Bolsheviks had…admitted publicly that they were all Nazi spies. All these Jewish old Bolsheviks said "Oh yes we've spent our whole career as Nazi spies," or something like that…The Nuremberg trials then were denounced at the time by so many respectable people…Robert Taft, ended up…denouncing them as just an outrageous…violation of justice. John F. Kennedy in his “Profiles In Courage” book…praised Robert Taft for his denunciation of the Nuremberg trials…” (Ron Unz, “Revisionist History of War Conference: Morning Session — Saturday, May 17. Time: 39:16)

During the Q/A, when asked about gas-chambers at Auschwitz he replied:

“I'm extremely skeptical of the mainstream story, in fact, one book I'd very much recommend would be a book[Breaking the Spell: The Holocaust: Myth & Reality] by Nicholas Kollerstrom…They ended up releasing the wartime decrypts of the German communications and those provide no indication of…huge numbers of people being killed and…the Zyklon B was really used for disinfection purposes…It was used basically to stamp out the typhus epidemic…to kill the lice.” (Ron Unz, “Revisionist History of War Conference: Morning Session — Saturday, May 17, Time: 46:41)

Further Stalinist–Communist trials in Poland would add more “evidence” and lend legitimacy to these exaggerations-fabrications providing the intellectual foundation for what would slowly evolve into the mainstream narrative-myth. Now, very important! The future of civilization may depend on this! Neither Vyshinsky, nor the major judges and main creators of the mainstream Holocaust narrative were Jews. In his book “Nazi Gas Chambers: The Roots of the Story”, Holocaust researcher, chemist, and living Galileo who spent almost 4 years in jail for first writing a chemistry report that doubted the official government-coerced-competition-immune narrative and then for publishing further criticisms of mainstream narrative, Germar Rudolf, concludes:

“The Polish underground inside and outside the camps invented and spread gas-chamber rumors throughout the war, with both Jews and non-Jews participating. At war’s end and thereafter, the communist Polish judiciary wrote the Nazi-gas-chamber narrative…To this day, their narrative is being taught and believed worldwide, and today even enforced by penal law in most Western countries. Just one Polish historian and three Polish judges played absolutely crucial roles in the formation of this narrative…As far as I can verify, none of them had a Jewish background.” (Germar Rudolf, “Nazi Gas Chambers: The Roots of the Story”, p. 119)

For obvious and understandable reasons which have nothing to do with some grand malicious conspiracy, the increasingly “Zionized” Jews would incorporate this non-Jewish-designed evolving narrative into their growing Zionist ideology-mythology-identity, which is always looking for evidence to show how uncivilized-irrational-evil the fellow homo sapiens who have not absorbed a “Jewish Identity” can be, and thus the need to live apart in their own ‘Jewish State’.

Unfortunately, naive thinkers would erroneously accuse “The Jews” of plotting “The Holocaust Lie” for sinister control, which would then gain Zionist ideology-mythology even more sympathy and power, which would naively be used to destroy freedom of speech by making Holocaust denial illegal. This would then erroneously “prove” to naive thinkers that “The Jews” plotted the whole thing from the beginning as part of some ‘formal conspiracy’, increasing anti-Jewish sentiment, motivating more naive Zionism and Zionist-led intellectual persecution in an endless cycle of vilification, censorship and the further disastrous “Zionification” of the West.

Consider the case of former German lawyer and political activist Horst Mahler who was sentenced several times to a cumulative 14 years in jail for questioning the mainstream Holocaust narrative. Horst mentioned the following somewhat scary statement on April 19th, 2017, as part of a longer anti-Jewish rant (Mahler’s speech before returning to prison, April 19th, 2017):

“Jews are on a divine mission to destroy humanity. The Bible states this categorically.”

I believe that Mr. Mahler is making very understandable intellectual errors, and putting him in jail over such fallacies is a cruel and counterproductive barbarity that does nothing to overcome them, and further contributes to anti-Jewish fallacies by once again making it appear to many as though “The Jews” as a group, or even more misguided, as a “race”, want to silence criticism for nefarious purposes. Former United States Special Envoy for Monitoring and Combating Antisemitism, Deborah Lipstadt, wisely opposes Holocaust Denial laws, but the “reason” of a few intellectuals is no match for the understandably ignorant, negligent, scared and vengeful Jewish masses and naive wannabe-heroic politicians, who, being equal homo sapiens like the rest of us, are just as susceptible to tribalistic mob behavior and the uncivilized criminalization of ideas. I have little doubt in my mind that if most people questioning the mainstream Holocaust narrative did so in a thoughtful, scholarly manner, free of the usual anti-Jewish “tropes”, as myself, Germar and Jewish-born Ron Unz do, Jews and their understandably concerned supporters would not react the way they do, and Holocaust Denial laws would not exist. Unfortunately for every Germar-Unz-like researcher-doubter-denier, we have 10,000 people making errors similar to Mahler, understandably scaring Jews-supporters into their own lynch-mob mentality, leading to coercion-violence via denial laws, and understandably fooling everyone into thinking every “denier” is some potentially malicious antisemite.

This can’t be stressed enough, it is vitally important to see the Holocaust and emerging Holocaustianity and ‘Holocaustianized Zionism’ for what it really is, a complex myth which understandably fooled Jews who then fooled the West. Unz elaborates on the mythical, NOT Jewish-conspired, narrative:

“I would bet…that virtually all of the supporters of the Holocaust these days actually believe in it, …in terms of the prominent academics or people sort of pushing it, they all believe in it… they may be sort of like nervous and skeptical about different elements of it, you know, particular details or something like that. I’d assume almost all of them probably believe in it. Because, again, it’s been part of the sort of framework that they’ve grown up with their entire lives… The fact that, for example, it was created by one group[inmates] and then picked up by another group[soviets] and then heavily promoted by a third group[Jews-Zionists]. I mean, that’s the way it is with lots of sort of stories or issues over time. And it’s just that, you know, different groups at different points had different incentives to sort of promote it or, you know, even came to believe it or something like that.” (Ron Unz: Analyzing the Holocaust with Germar Rudolf and Jorge Besada, Time 2:13:10)

Holocaust myths understandably added an immense fervor-fanaticism-stubbornness and self-righteousness to an already flawed Zionist ideology-identity. In his excellent book “Rise and Kill First: The Secret History of Israel’s Targeted Assassinations.“ Ronen Bergman writes:

“Israel’s reliance on assassination as a military tool did not happen by chance, but rather stems from the revolutionary and activist roots of the Zionist movement, from the trauma of the Holocaust, and from the sense among Israel’s leaders and citizens that the country and its people are perpetually in danger of annihilation and that, as in the Holocaust, no one will come to their aid when that happens.” (p. xxii)

Further Similarities between Zionism-Israel and Socialism-Soviet Union.

Like the Soviets, the Zionists erroneously see themselves as the vanguard of civilization in an allegedly backward Islamic world plagued by “irrationality” and “hate”. The fallacies-injustices of Zionism increased anti-Jewish fallacies and religious extremism, reversing the Islamic world’s path towards individual rights-Capitalism. The more poverty and extremism Zionism brings as the “Zionized” West keeps destroying all governments in the Middle East that properly reflect the anti-Zionist views of their citizens, the easier it becomes for the mostly white, secularized, “followers of the science”, and LGBT-rights-respecting Zionists to fool themselves and their fellow white Europeans and Americans into the righteousness and superiority of their ideology and “Jewish State”, and how they are beacons of “Western Civilization” at the forefront of some “clash of civilizations” which is best managed by the ‘Great Leader’ and “expert” in “terrorism” Benjamin Netanyahu. Leading Zionist ideologue Ben Shapiro mentioned: “I would gladly waive the born-in-the-USA requirement for the presidency for Bibi. I mean, the guy is just an incredible leader.”

It really is that simple. When David Ben Gurion declared victory and the establishment of Israel in 1949, then US president Harry S. Truman was wisely advised by the State Department and others against recognizing it, but in his own words:

“I’m sorry, gentlemen, but I have to answer to hundreds of thousands who are anxious for the success of Zionism; I do not have hundreds of thousands of Arabs among my constituents.” (Judis, J. B. (2014). Genesis: Truman, American Jews, and the Origins of the Arab/Israeli Conflict. P. 209)

There were about 2 million Jews in New York in 1949 and just 10,000-20,000 Muslims.

Ignorant of the great liberal thinkers-economists like Adam Smith, Carl Menger and his ‘Austrian School of Economics’ and their wisdom regarding the non-designed emergence of the modern free market liberal order, the Zionists and many Jews naively tried to take credit for it, when in reality, as with the Soviets, they are inadvertently destroying it.

Just like the Soviets fooled themselves into coercing millions, killing the “profiteering” Kulaks and the allegedly “irrational” Christians who were calling the atheistic Soviets “evil” and “Satanic”, so do the Zionists feel justified in coercing everyone into their ideology, especially the distraught, brutalized, and understandably radicalized Palestinians and Muslims who may say awful things about the Zionists. Israeli author of the great books ‘The Invention of the Jewish People’, and ‘The Invention of the Land of Israel’, Shlomo Sand, astutely mentioned that: “Zionism has become…. a sort of Stalinism”, that understandably attempts to coerce and ultimately kill all ideological opposition. CEO of the Anti-Defamation League Jonathan Greenblatt mentioned that: “Anti-Zionism is antisemitism”, and that: “Anti-Zionism is genocide”.

Mises writes:

"History speaks only to those people who know how to interpret it on the ground of correct theories."

Thus erroneous Socialist ideology-myths also led to erroneous interpretations of history (‘Marxian class theory’, etc.). Marx famously writes nonsense like: “The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.” The same could be said about Nazis and those who erroneously look for the keys to socioeconomic progress and its history in race-genetics. Likewise the increasingly “Zionized” Jews could easily cherry-pick facts, history, and instances of anti-Jewish fallacies to further fool themselves and those around them about the justice-wisdom of their ideology. As with the Soviets, they fooled themselves into criminalizing the very freedom of speech needed to overcome their myths.

Regardless of their chess champions and “scientific institutes”, the Soviets were as ignorant and negligent of economics and how their ideology was the problem, as the Zionists are regarding how to overcome anti-Jewish fallacies, achieve socioeconomic harmony, and how their misguided ideology has been and continues to be the root cause of so much socioeconomic chaos. And both myths-ideologies-cultures-identities inadvertently grew from coerced-competition-immune information that per Germar: “is most likely incorrect and leads to a mis-development, to disfigurations of society because it cannot freely develop the best way.”

Netanyahu once mentioned: “I know what America is. America is something that can easily be moved. Moved to the right direction.” And former PM Ariel Sharon told Shimon Peres: "don't worry about American pressure on Israel, we, the Jewish people control America, and the Americans know it." Many will erroneously see these statements and the immense power of the Zionists as the “obvious” result of some grand sinister conspiracy, when, again, no such thing is at play. When one properly understands the history and emergence of ideologies like Socialism and Zionism, and also reads biographies of Socialists like Lenin, Stalin, Trotsky, reformers like Gorbachev, and Zionists like David ben Gurion, Jabotinsky, Begin, and Netanyahu, it is easy to see how these men are just heads in Socialist and Zionist ideological hydras-movements that understandably arose due to the unplanned-undesigned emergence and complexity of the socioeconomic order in the case of Socialism, and Jew-Gentile “identity” co-evolution-relations. Erroneously attributing reason or conspiracy to evolved complex phenomena is the main source of mankind’s recent troubles, especially Jew-Gentile ones.

Once again it is vitally important to understand the role that statistics and shared ideology-interests-incentives, NOT conspiracy, play in the emergence and spread of ideologies and violence. For example, when some understandably angry Muslims killed staff of the Charlie Hebdo French magazine due to publishing offensive images of prophet Muhammad, this was NOT the result of some grand conspiracy by Muslims orchestrated from Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. In any ideology there will be a percentage of people who feel like lies and violence is justified, and it is this statistical process, NOT some grand ‘formal conspiracy’, that is the culprit. We can see this process in Jew-Gentile chaos via the emergence of groups like the Jewish Defense League (JDL) founded by Rabbi Meir Kahane which was officially classified as a "right-wing terrorist group" by the FBI (2001) and would terrorize critics of Zionism and Holocaust revisionists-deniers like fellow Jew David Cole who famously made a great documentary (‘David Cole in Auschwitz’) helping debunk the myth of mass-gassings and exterminations at Auschwitz.

Zionist ideology and emerging need to destroy all regimes critical of Zionism-Israel (Iraq, Libya, Syria, Lebanon, Iran, etc.) and their allies (Russia, China, etc.) continues to be what polarizes the planet as it did in WWII against Hitler. US Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, mentioned that: “Hamas and Hezbollah are proxies of Iran, and they’re tied in now with Russia and China… it is a new axis of evil.” This has led the “Zionized” US, largely on Bibi’s behalf, to continuously destroy the Middle East and grow its yearly military consumption to the point where by 2025 every year the US spends about 1.5 trillion dollars (an amount similar to the GDP of Spain) in national defense. According to one estimate by Grok (X-Twitter’s AI chatbot), creating all the buildings and infrastructure of a city in the US that could house 500,000 people like Miami, would cost about $250 billion dollars. From this, we can crudely estimate that about six Miami-sized cities could be built each year if—instead of consuming $1.5 trillion in wealth toward military spending—we produced the cities (or additional urban growth). This is one of the main reasons why China creates or grows its order by many Miami-sized cities-growth full of skyscrapers every year, while the US goes deeper in debt and has us where we are today, where about 20 percent of our taxes go just to pay the interest on the massive $37+ trillion debt. Millions of these dollars eventually make it to hundreds of think-tanks, “Zionized” Churches, Holocaust museums, and AIPAC which then spew Zionist fallacies-myths just like the Soviet Union’s universities, Comintern(Communist International) and overall state would spread Marxist nonsense-mythology while silencing dissent. And just as important, an incentive structure that incentivized millions into both pushing-joining the ideology, and later resisting change.

Given the above, it is a statistical certainty that “Zionized” people will do nefarious things like potential involvement in JFK murder, 9/11 (famous dancing Israelis), painting swastikas, etc. to sustain the ideology and attack its critics, especially given the fact that so many critics of Zionism like Nick Fuentes, can be easily found making anti—Jewish and other fallacies. This then gives the impression to naive thinkers that some grand conspiracy is taking place by “The Jews” when no such thing is at play.

Just like Soviet bureaucrats would rise in the bureaucracy by showing Socialist ideological zeal and denouncing those who lacked purity and fervor for the faith-ideology, so has Zionist ideological zeal and its naive and simplistic battle against antisemitism, and thus critics of Zionism, now totally dominates most Western politicians-governments, culminating in Netanyahu getting more than one standing ovation per minute in his last speech before the US congress in July, 2024. Party-ideology-faithful bureaucrats like US Representative Randy Fine (R-FL), a man who has never recommended a book or had an interview or discussion with anyone about anything of substance, and has risen in politics due to adherence to the ruling faith (ideology of Zionism just like it was Socialism for the Soviets), mention that: “Today, Tucker Carlson is the most dangerous antisemite in America.” Naïve simple-minded American politicians, especially religious ones in the Republican Party like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, go to Israel, immerse themselves in the history of Jewish suffering, are shown antisemitic statements by understandably traumatized and radicalized Palestinians, and then start passing ‘hate speech’ laws and see it as their moral duty to do essentially whatever the ‘Great Leader’ Benjamin Netanyahu feels is necessary to fight ‘the terrorists’, antisemites, ‘the world’s oldest hatred’ and so on.

The Soviet Union’s central bank (Gosbank) would create money to sustain the bureaucracy-thinktanks-ideology, similarly the US Federal Reserve keeps creating the necessary trillions to finance the 1.5 trillion yearly battle of good vs. evil and Zionist ideology-mythology, etc. To significant degrees the entire Western World and much of its economy has been “Zionized” just like it was once dominated by the ideological and financial incentives associated with coercive religious priesthoods, slavery, and Socialism.

An echo-chamber of negligence and incentive structures similar to that which sustained and expanded Socialism, likewise sustains Zionism and its “intellectuals” who dare not debate fellow Jew Dave Smith, and much less Holocaust revisionists like Germar Rudolf or Ron Unz. The courageous 5 time MMA world champion Jake Shields tried in vain to get some mainstream Holocaust “scholar” to debate Germar Rudolf. Professor of History at Sacramento State University, Michael G. Vann, agreed to debate Germar and understandably provided little intellectual opposition-competition. The same would have happened had the Soviets (and Nazis), instead of criminalizing dissent, had sought out Ludwig von Mises for debate.

Conclusion.

Unfortunately the same fallacies just keep repeating and expanding the polarizations. Anti-Zionists naively call the Zionists “genocidal” given the immense destruction of life and property in Gaza, and the Zionists’ desire to make it inhospitable and expel the Gazans. Calling it a genocide implies a clear malice and naively labels the Zionists as the guilty party in this horrible chaos without understanding the complex evolution of ideas and incentives which guide their actions. Referring to “The Jews” as the allegedly malicious killers of Christ, plotters of Communism and the Bolshevik Revolution among other fallacies is what created the disastrous Zionist identity-ideology to begin with. How can the Zionists be blamed when hardly anyone in the world has the wisdom, means, and courage to tell them that the mass-gassings extermination narrative, which is at the very core of their very identity and world-view, is a myth? From the moment Israelis are old enough they are totally “Zionized” and taught that through some “irrational hatred” non-Jews will want to harm them and that the Holocaust proves this. Every year 25,000-35,000 Israeli high school students make a pilgrimage to Auschwitz to indoctrinate them in this faith that ultimately worships the nebulous concept of “irrational evil” and has ultimately transformed Jews, from humble God-fearing people fully deserving of much sympathy given the history of ill treatment, to the most inadvertently dangerous oppressors and murderers. Since without Zionism WWII and subsequent misery could have easily been avoided, as well as all the suffering and chaos in the Middle East that has prevented otherwise skyrocketing peace and prosperity, on a per-capita basis Zionism has likely been the deadliest ideology homo sapiens has thus far fallen for. Unz (again, born Jewish himself) writes that: “in per capita terms Jews were the greatest mass-murderers of the twentieth century, holding that unfortunate distinction by an enormous margin and with no other nationality coming even remotely close.”

Very important! Even if Hitler and enough Germans had carried out the Holocaust as widely believed, it would not change the seemingly obvious fact that such actions were the understandable result of fallacies and “ideas that group men”, and not some quasi-mystical “irrational evil” non-sense. Homo sapiens slaughtering each other is quite common and there would be little difference in the Holocaust compared to dropping two nukes on the Japanese, and the purposeful killing of German civilians via Allied bombardment. Arthur ‘Bomber’ Harris the head of British Bomber Command in WWII, saw civilian death as necessary, encouraged, and totally justified. He wrote that:

“It should be emphasized that the destruction of houses, public utilities, transport and lives; the creation of a refugee problem on an unprecedented scale; and the breakdown of morale both at home and at the battle fronts by fear of extended and intensified bombing, are accepted and intended aims of bombing policy. They are not by-products of attempts to hit factories.” (Letter from Harris to Sir Arthur Street, Air Ministry, October 25, 1942)

Although there are a few intellectuals that can properly sympathize-with and understand the fallacies fueling the chaos, at the level of mainstream intellectuals, the public, and politicians, we just have “us vs. them”, “good vs. evil”, moral pontification and condemnations thus “no social cooperation is possible where such an attitude prevails.”

Mainstream influencers like Candace Owens have done a superb job showing the disastrous Zionification of America and its never-ending Zionist-inspired wars and censorship, yet regarding the destruction of Gaza she mentions: "What we are watching right now is the Synagogue of Satan led by Bibi Netanyahu.” Left-wing, secular-Darwinian Jews-Zionists and their massive overrepresentation in “the science” and big-Tech can easily ignore-smear Candace and anyone making any kind of religious-based criticism of Zionism. This is just like Christians calling the Soviets evil and Satanic which only grew the Soviet’s power-fallacies-tyranny. It is obvious to me that Candace is a wonderful and caring mother, a pious Catholic concerned with the suffering of all human beings and obviously the people in Gaza, but her statements and fallacies above have understandably caused the Zionists to label her as the ‘Antisemite of the Year’. Someone to be vilified, eventually be made a criminal due to ‘hate speech’ laws, and then brutally killed if necessary. Again, not as some conspiracy plotted by Great Leader Bibi, but simply due to ideological fervor and statistics. Neither Bibi nor Lenin were Satanic, they were-are “harmful agents” executing ideologies described by “honourable and well-meaning scholars who never recognized the offspring they produced" leading to “the greatest crimes of our time…that had the enthusiastic support of millions of people who were guided by moral impulses.” Similarly, Jake Shields tweeted regarding Israel: “It is time for this demonic nation to come to an end”. Also, Jake’s friend, Dan Bilzerian (‘The King of Instagram’ with 30+ million followers) tweets: “Jews should pay holocaust reparations to the families of the 60 million Christians they killed during the Bolshevik genocide.” Again, like Hitler-others, erroneously-unfairly blaming “The Jews” for the inadvertent over-representation of many Jews in Socialism. Nick Fuentes too has a profound understanding of the disastrous Zionification of the US Government and Western World, yet by preaching for some white Catholic ethnostate among other fallacies, Nick, and similarly Candace, Jake and Dan, and many other courageous and knowledgeable critics of Zionism, who are in many ways helping save civilization, also inadvertently help fuel the ideology-chaos and censorship. Anti-Jewish fallacies fuel Zionist ones and vice versa. To me these people are heroes. Anyone who knowing that they will be persecuted-bankrupted has the courage to voice their opinions, and thus engage in the vital competition of ideas which creates civilization, while respecting the property and freedom of speech of others, should be seen as a hero regardless of whether they are right or wrong.

How do we get out of this mess? Again: “when we understand everything, we will forgive everything.”

And in order to “understand everything” as best we can, which not only includes the emergence of ideologies, fallacies and history, but also how to solve our problems and achieve the socioeconomic prosperity we can have, we just need freedom of speech and emerging competition of ideas. Actually, no, we also need the freedom to keep our wealth. All action requires two things, the information which guides it, and the wealth that must be consumed while the action takes place. In the US I still have the freedom to criticize all the foolish things the Government does, which includes sustaining our ‘Holocaustianized Zionism’ religion, its $1.5 trillion military, and since the beginning of the Oct. 7th Israeli-Hamas war, over $30 billion sent to Israel so that it can sustain the destruction of Gaza. Thus freedom of speech by itself does NOT prevent bad actions or ideologies from happening if via taxation or inflation they can still obtain the wealth needed to carry them out. This lack of freedom is what allowed, per Germar, “disfigurations of society” via Socialism and Zionism, and is all that we need to discover and spread the best ways to reorder it.

The Soviet Union and underlying socialist myths were ultimately overcome, not in some great war, but by helping enough socialists themselves overcome their fallacies. If Russia, a relatively modern free market economy where over 50% of its population is employed in the private sector by over 3 million private sector businesses, is now led by Putin, a former KGB agent whose job at one time was to help enforce socialist myths, why should we not have faith that a likewise naive and dangerously Zionized Mossad agent today may be a future leader in the area? The Russians and Chinese got their reformers via Gorbachev and Deng. The Zionists, being the wisest of them all, with the most Nobel Laureates, likewise have many potential Gorbachevs like Yaakov Sharett, a former intelligence officer and the son of the former prime minister of Israel Moshe Sharett, who mentions: “in the end Israel is a country occupying and abusing another people.”

Mises tells us:

"Liberalism is rationalistic. It maintains that it is possible to convince the immense majority that peaceful cooperation within the framework of society better serves their rightly understood interests than mutual battling and social disintegration. It has full confidence in man’s reason. It may be that this optimism is unfounded and that the liberals have erred. But then there is no hope left for mankind’s future." (Mises, ‘Human Action’, p. 157)

Without the belief that "it is possible to convince the immense majority", the effort to educate and overcome Socialist, anti-Jewish and Zionist fallacies will not exist so the calamities will continue and “then there is no hope left for mankind’s future.”

Once again it is vitally important to see our Jew-Gentile chaos as the emergence of understandable fallacies. Yet another one of these fallacies significantly responsible for much of the chaos is to push for some mythical 2-state solution. I understand and sympathize with Netanyahu when he mentions:

"Every area that we evacuate we've received terrible terror against us. It happened in South Lebanon, in Gaza, also today in Samaria .... and therefore I clarify that....any other arrangement in the future, the state of Israel has to control on the entire area from the river to the sea ...This truth I say to our American friends... And I also stop the attempt to impose on us a reality [two state solution] that will jeopardize us. A prime minister in Israel has to be able to say no, even to the best of friends. To say no when you need to, and to say yes when you can." (Netanyahu, Jan. 18th, 2024)

Bibi and the Zionists are correct. A Palestinian state would just mean a far deadlier and better armed anti-Zionist armed resistance movement. Technology is making it increasingly easy for small groups like Hezbollah, Hamas, and the Houthis to develop deadlier and more sophisticated weapons, and likewise the Israeli-Zionist ideology has better ways to spy on the whole planet and likewise silence-coerce-kill its critics. It is absurdly obvious, as reality is increasingly showing, how this process can only end in a final world-war-like calamity-tyranny.

Also, few self-respecting Muslims who really believe in God, in the moral duty to support what is just and fight what is unjust, and knows the history of Zionism and its numerous fallacies, will understandably tolerate the unnecessary-unjust coercion of some ‘Jewish State’ on anyone. What they will do is forgive with compassion, just like we can likewise expect Jews to forgive those who naively make anti-Jewish fallacies.

The Zionist ideologues in Israel that are currently destroying civilization are also in many ways helping to save it. Bibi, and many in the upper echelons of the Israeli government have a superb understanding of freedom, Capitalism and free markets. This was on full display on June 11, 2025 when the great freemarketeer and Argentinian President Javier Milei was invited to give a speech in the Knesset to thunderous applause and also given the Genesis Prize. Since “Leftists”-Socialists not only spread civilization-destroying economic fallacies, but also the erroneous idea that somehow Zionism and Israel is some “Fascist” or Capitalist state “exploiting” indigenous minorities, this helps Zionist leadership like Bibi who today are staunch Capitalists fool themselves into believing that somehow Israel-Zionism are the vanguard or defenders of Capitalism.

“Zionized” US Senator Lindsey Graham tweets regarding Trump’s provocations against Venezuela: “Venezuela has long been a safe haven for narco-terrorists, and it has had an unhealthy relationship with Iran, Russia and other bad actors.” The ‘Mossad Commentary’ X-account (@MOSSADil) tweeted:

“WHAT’S WITH THE U.S. MILITARY BUILDUP OFF VENEZUELA’S COAST?

…beneath the surface, this operation targets something far bigger: the financial lifeline of global jihad. For years, elements inside the Venezuelan regime have partnered with Hezbollah, Iran’s most dangerous proxy, to move narcotics, launder billions, and fund terrorism abroad. So while America fights the drug crisis at home, it’s also cutting off the same money pipeline that fuels rockets, militias, and chaos in the Middle East. It’s not just a war on drugs. It’s a war on the economy of terror.”

Again, most of the warmongering we see today is an outgrowth of Jew-Gentile misunderstandings leading to Zionism and its countless ramifications. Yes, Socialism is disastrous, but it should be overcome via a proper focus on free market education which was the key to Milei’s triumphs. Again, Socialist, anti-Jewish, and Zionist fallacies must be overcome via reason, logic, tolerance, sympathy and education. Vilification and armed resistance towards people who make mistakes is itself a mistake.

If we can get enough leaders and influencers to better understand real freedom and Capitalism, we can easily transform the current flawed Israeli State into a new state, free of the Zionist fallacies, that can not only finally end the flawed ideology that has been the swimmer’s kick that keeps polarizing the world into conflict, but serve as a beacon of free market education to the world. Please find-watch ‘A Free Market One State Solution To The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict’.

Henry Hazlitt:

“A minority is in a very awkward position. The individuals in it can't afford to be just as good as the individuals in the majority. If they hope to convert the majority they have to be much better; and the smaller the minority, the better they have to be. They have to think better. They have to know more. They have to write better. They have to have better controversial manners. Above all, they have to have far more courage. And they have to be infinitely patient.” (Hazlitt, "The Wisdom of Henry Hazlitt")

Mises:

"Everyone carries a part of society on his shoulders; no one is relieved of his share of responsibility by others. And no one can find a safe way out for himself if society is sweeping towards destruction. Therefore, everyone, in his own interests, must thrust himself vigorously into the intellectual battle. None can stand aside with unconcern; the interests of everyone hang on the result. Whether he chooses or not, every man is drawn into the great historical struggle, the decisive battle into which our epoch has plunged us." (Mises, “Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis”, p. 515)

Mises:

"... in the field of social organization and economic policies. Here the best theories are useless if not supported by public opinion. They cannot work if not accepted by a majority of the people. Whatever the system of government may be, there cannot be any question of ruling a nation lastingly on the ground of doctrines at variance with public opinion. In the end the philosophy of the majority prevails. In the long run there cannot be any such thing as an unpopular system of government...The supremacy of public opinion determines not only the singular role that economics occupies in the complex of thought and knowledge. It determines the whole process of human history... great men cannot succeed in adjusting social conditions to their plans if they do not convince public opinion.

The flowering of human society depends on two factors: the intellectual power of outstanding men to conceive sound social and economic theories, and the ability of these or other men to make these ideologies palatable to the majority." (Mises, “Human Action”, p. 859)

Further suggestions:

The documentary “Stalin’s Judge, Andrey Vyshinsky, tells us about the Holocaust, freedom, and 'Austrian Economics'” provides an hour-long introduction to both the emergence of Holocaust myths and vital free market concepts.

Germar Rudolf’s ‘The Holocaust: Proven at Nuremberg Reviewing the Evidence Presented at the International Military Tribunal’.

Ron Unz: Analyzing the Holocaust with Germar Rudolf and Jorge Besada

The 7+ hour documentary ‘An Evolutionary Analysis of Socialism, Antisemitism, Zionism, Holocaustianity, And Other Myths Which Lured Bright And Well-Intentioned People To Disaster.’ Provides a more thorough-complete analysis of all fallacies.

Germar Rudolf manages https://holocausthandbooks.com/ which has 8 great documentaries and 50+ volumes dealing with everything related to the Holocaust.

Former Jew Paul Eisen’s article “How I Became a Holocaust Denier” and other writings are a great way for Jews to learn about the courageous intellectual journey of one of their own. (audio)

My book “The Freedom Intellectual Reconquista: The Growing ‘Austrian Economics’ Worldwide Revolution And Resulting Dissolution Of Myths Arising From Biochemical And Socioeconomic Complexity (Germ Theory, Socialism, Antisemitism, Zionism)” ( free PDF, free audio ) provides an even more detailed analysis of the above, however, it does not go into Holocaust exaggerations.

I can be reached at hayekian@gmail.com, besada.com